First Congregational Church UCC
"The Big White Church in Berlin Heights"

5 East Main Street
P.O. Box 66
Berlin Heights, OH 44814
419-588-2102 email: bhcong@verizon.net


History of The Big White Church of Berlin Heights

The first settlers arrived in the township in 1808.  At the time, the township and town were named Eldridge.  They were named after Mr. Eldridge who owned most of the land in the area.

The first religious group in the area to meet was the Methodists who held classes in homes as early as 1812.  Then the Baptists started a church in 1818.  The Congregational Church was started on February 25, 1823 in the log schoolhouse that stood near the corner of what is now Main Street and Bellamy Road.  The log building was 16x20 feet with a stone fireplace that occupied the entire end of the building.

A group of people me with Rev. Alfred H Betts and Rev. Lot B. Sullivan on February 25, 1823 to organize the Congregational Church.  The church remained Congregational for one year and then it became Presbyterian.  This was due to the strength and aid that they received from the district Presbytery.  I 1865, it again became Congregational.

Rev. Betts was pastor until 1829.  In 1830, nine men of the church organized the Congregational Society.  It was largely due to the energy of this group that a church building was erected in 1832 where the Methodist Church currently stands.  It is recorded that the entire lot including where both the Congregational and Methodist churches stand today was purchased for $9.00.

The nine men were Noah Hill, Amos Hine, Moses Burnham, John Fuller, Charles Kellogg, Jared Hine, Simon C. Stimpson, Joseph Otis and Sheldon Hine.  It is noted that it was 1878 before women were considered worthy of membership in the select organization.

In 1832 the name of the town was changed from Eldridge to Berlin and later to Berlin Heights because of another Berlin in Ohio.

In 1847 work was started on building a new church and the old church was moved to West Main Street where it was used as a “Free Discussion Hall”.

The church was built with a porch on the front which was later enclosed making the interior somewhat larger.  Another change was that a steeple was added a number of years later.  There is no written record of this, but you can see in the attic where the original roof and shingles were cut away to build the steeple.  The remaining shingles show a number of years of wear.

The original pews had doors on them and at the time of the building members paid from $15.00 to $60.00 for their pew.

Some time before the township library was started there was a library in what is not the “cry” room.  It was open to the public.  There was an entrance on the west side of the church where the outside door to the Bird’s Nest is now.

In 1849, several members contributed $500.00 for the creation of Western Reserve University, now known as Case Western Reserve University.  In recognition of their generosity, the University Trustees granted a “charity” scholarship to any male student, living in Berlin Heights or the township that is pursuing a liberal arts degree.  The scholarship will continue as long as the church is in existence.  Six young men from our community have used it to date.

Around 1900, a basement was dug and the dining room and kitchen were built.  About the same time, the church at Ceylon was built under the Congregational Church’s sponsorship.  The ministers from this church preached in the Ceylon Church for a number of years until it was taken over by the Huron Evangelical Church in 1914.

The church building has suffered a couple of disasters in its lifetime.  In April 1918 the church was struck by lightning.  The roof was badly damaged and the sanctuary ceiling partly destroyed.  Even so this day anyone going into the attic over the sanctuary can see the charred beams.  Church services were held in the church basement until the church was repaired.

One Sunday afternoon in June 1944, a wind and thunder storm hit the area.  A large maple tree on the west side of the church blew over taking out the middle sanctuary window and damaging some of the siding on the west side.  The branches of the tree reached the middle aisle.

In 1940 four Sunday school rooms were built on the back of the church.  These were given by Winfield and Mildred Lippus.  A new Hammond organ was given by Mrs. Linnie Hassenflue in memory of her husband.  We are still using this organ.

1956 saw the building of a new social hall, more Sunday school rooms, restrooms, kitchen and a church office complex.  The old basement was partitioned off for Sunday school rooms.   The cost of the social hall and kitchen was paid for by Mr. & Mrs. George Ritter and named for Mrs. Ritter’s parents Fred and Maud Fowler who were active in the church in the early 1900’s.

There are a few things that happened during the lifetime of the church that seem strange to us today.   One of these was the church and township ordering of a certain “Rachel Taylor” to depart from the township of Eldridge.  Where she went or where in the wilderness she was expected to go is not recorded.  It is not told what her crime was.

In 1890 there was a bank robbery at the bank which was west of what is now the basket shop.  Some of the town’s people were standing on the west side of the church shooting at the robbers.  In turn the robbers were shooting back.  One of the shots hit one of the windows over the front church door.  The hole is still there in the red glass for all to see.

The “Bird’s Nest” had been a balcony until it was enclosed and used as a Sunday school room.  It was also used by the school for a classroom.  In 1957 after the Fowler Room addition was built the large square room (Lippus Room) above the Fowler room was used by the school as a classroom. 

Since the church was started back in 1823 we have had 44 pastors.  One pastor Milton J. Norton served from 1903-1907.  He was a native son of the church.  He was born on what is now Bellamy Road on the farm where Pauline Malone now lives.

Two of our pastors Rev. Raymond W. Steiner and Rev. Harvey A Parker died while serving our church.  Rev. Steiner died in 1936 from appendicitis at the age of 43.  Rev. Parker died at the age of 33 from Leukemia in 1960.

The 44 pastors and the dates of their service are as follows:

1823-1829       Alfred H. Betts             1900-1903       W.H. Hannaford

1829-1832       Everton Judson             1903-1907       Milton J. Norton

1832-1833       Erastus Curtiss              1908-1911       A.J. Burnett

1833-1834       Eldrad Barker               1911-1912       G.E.E. Lindquist

1836-1838       I.B. Parlin                     1912-1913       Allen L. Eddy

1838-1839       James Crawford                       1913-1926       William Cady

1840-1851       John C. Sherwin                       1926-1929       Franklin L. Graff

1851-1852       James Scott                  1930-1936       Raymond W. Steiner

1852-1853       G.C. Judson                 1936-1945       Joseph H. Dudley

1853-1860       F.S. Deming                 1945-1948       John W. Townsend

1860-1863       E.M. Cravath               1948-1952       Grafton M. Thomas

1864-1865       T.B. Penfield                1952-1955       Clarence A. Colwell

1865-1869       George Candee                        1956-1960       Harvey A. Parker

1871-1874       Levi Loring                   1961-1964       Charles A. Trautman

1874-1878       A.D. Hale                     1965-1972       W. Osborne Hoover, Jr.

1878-1879       Alfred C. Wright                       1973-1981       Alex E. Dandar

1880- 1881      A.M. Pipes                   1982-1983       Roy Howell

1882-1886       Wm M. Jones               1984-1988       Jeffery Hammond

1890-1892       D.R. James                   1988-1994       Stephen Evans

1893-1896       George Hill                   1995-1997       John Ferguson

1896-1900       B.R. Chaney                 1999-present    Joyce Schroer

Prepared by Lawrence Johns                                        February 2008